While Jake and his crew are fishing,on Pirate IslandCubby discovers a magical bottle with a message in it. It is a clue to a secret legendary treasure of a fisherman pirate named Captain Fisher hidden on Never Land. Jake's crew aren't the only ones who want to hunt for this treasure, Captain Hook knew of Captain Fisher treasure and was determined to claim it as his own with Smee Hook followed the young pirate crew to the first location on Never Land mention by the map Rockin Rock Captain Hook manage to swipe the bottle from the puny pirate team. Fortunately Jake and his mateys remember the path to Captain Fisher's secret treasure once they reach the top of the Twisty Tree the followed the young pirate crew to Rockin Rock when he swipes the bottle from the puny pirate team. Fortunately Jake and his mateys remember the path to Captain Fisher's secret treasure once they reach the top of the Twisty Tree the pirate team the locate treasure at Crocodile Creek.
Jake and his crew race down to the creek but Hook and Mr. Smee reach the creek first but before they retrieve the treasure at the bottom of the creek, Tick-Tock the Crocodile prevents Hook and Smee from getting the treasure chest chasing the duo away from his lair.Now with Tick-Tock circling the water of the creek the young pirates needed a safer means to retrieve the treasure Cubby come up with the idea to fish the treasure from the creek only for Captain Hook to snatch the chest from the young pirates when they left their guard down before flee back to the Jolly Roger. In order to get the the treasure back Jake pretends to be Captain Fisher to scare Captain Hook into giving the treasure back but Hook soon learns that he's been tricked and gives chase after sea pup Izzy quickly use her pixie dust flying the crew back to Pirate Island were the young pirates discover what Captain Fisher treasure is a set of golden fishing pole for each of them.Meanwhile back on the Jolly Roger Mr. Smee attempts to cheer Captain Hook up by fishing up their own message in a bottle from the Never Sea only for Hook to fish out Tick-Tock from the Never Sea who begins pursuing Hook and Smee yet again aboard the Jolly Roger.